ECR 2015 Quiz Case #3 (competition closed)

ESR_News_Header_blog_LO_SZ_01

This month we’re offering you a third and final chance to win free registration for ECR 2015, Europe’s biggest and best imaging meeting. Simply leave your answer to the question below, as a comment on this post, before January 26 (comments now closed). All correct answers will be entered into a draw and a winner will be selected by the editor of ESR News. The answer and winner will be announced by the end of January. Please note that the competition is open to ESR members only.

15-01a

15-01b

Question: Which is the most likely diagnosis?

A: Partial tear anterior cruciate ligament
B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

Click here to reveal the answer

Congratulations to the winner of this month’s competition, Dr. Victor Konikov, who recieves free registration for ECR 2015!

Thank you to all participants and well done to those who got the correct answer. Keep an eye out for the February issue of ESR News and your chance to win a new ESOR-related prize.

Be Sociable, Share!
    20
    Jan 2015
    POSTED BY
    POSTED IN ,
    DISCUSSION 148 Comments

    148 Responses to : ECR 2015 Quiz Case #3 (competition closed)

    1. Ankur Arora says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    2. Amol Jagdale says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    3. Anushri Parakh says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    4. Philip Yoong says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    5. Muddassir Rashid says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    6. Dmytro Petrenko says:

      The answer is B (mucoid degeneration ACL)

    7. Darka Hadnadjev Simonji says:

      B:Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    8. Darka Hadnadjev Simonji says:

      B:Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    9. bayhaqi says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    10. Mohammed Noeman says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    11. choman says:

      B- mucoid degeneration of ACL.

    12. giovanni tosi says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    13. Dragos Cuzino says:

      B.Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    14. Hans says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    15. Hugo Costa says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    16. Dagmara says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    17. kalpana bansal says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    18. Eva Narvestad says:

      Answer: B

    19. Ksenia Katanandova says:

      By this T1 sag image I couldn’t definitely choose mycoid degeneration of ACL, though it’s the more likely diagnosis. The ligament is swallen, but I’m not sure that it’ s not ruptured. At this picture I don’t see the secondary signs of ACL tear, but I have no other MR pictures (PD, T2 etc.) So, for me, the answer B. is the MORE likely diagnosis, not the most likely.

    20. priyanka gahlot says:

      B. MUCOID DEGENERATION ANTERIOR CRUCIATE LIGAMENT

    21. Mauro Cesar Silveira Moreira says:

      B

    22. Max R says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    23. Monika Serg says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    24. Mari N. says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration of the ACL

    25. Answer: B. Mucoid degeneration of the ACL

    26. answer B.

      mucoid degeneration of ACL

    27. Isabel Elía says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    28. Serife says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    29. B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    30. Ramakrishna says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    31. Jan Jurrit Hof says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    32. Ali Amutamaiz says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    33. Victor Konikov says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    34. gus says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    35. guillermo blanco says:

      answer B mucoid degeneration of ACL.

    36. Hassan Ali Ahmed Mahmoud says:

      Answer B- mucous degeneration of ACL

    37. Remco de Cuijper says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    38. Pilar Servent says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    39. Mohamed Hussien says:

      mucoid degeneration of ACL. there are intact posterior fibres , better evaluation by other sequences ( PD FS)

    40. Isabel Salmerón says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration ACL

    41. Fabien HO says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament
      Hope I can win the registration yay

    42. DR_tian says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament
      Hope I can win the registration yay

    43. Merli Ilves says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament.

    44. Kumar Rahul says:

      Answer is ( B ). Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    45. Cyrille Naim says:

      The answer is b. Mucoid degeneration of the ACL.

    46. Hans Sigurd Nilssen says:

      B. mucoid degeneration of ACL.

    47. Dr anjum mehdi says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament.

    48. Dragos Olariu says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    49. Francesco Giganti says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    50. vainak n says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    51. SUBRAMANIYAN says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    52. DAYANA PASTOR says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    53. Mushhad Ehsan says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    54. Gaha Mehdi says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    55. Roberto Ovalle says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    56. nino says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    57. Dr. Musa Karim says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    58. varun l says:

      Answer B:Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    59. Maria Sidiropoulou says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    60. kalirajan Kalidos says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    61. Ronald Antulov says:

      Answer B:Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    62. IBRAHIM AL MAIS says:

      The answer is B:mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    63. gokcan says:

      The answer is B ( Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament)

    64. Aleksandar Janicijevic says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    65. Cata S. says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    66. Rahim Hajirajabi says:

      Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    67. R_Shulm says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the ACL is the correct answer, however some would argue that mucoid degeneration is actually the sequelae of multiple chronic/prior low grade partial years of the ACL…

    68. Puneet gupta says:

      B:Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    69. Krzysztof Kansy says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    70. Daliborka says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament
      Because secondary signs of ACL injury are absent at least in these images.

    71. Niyaz Roshan Khatri says:

      B.Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    72. Ercan Ayaz says:

      B : Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    73. stoica iuliana says:

      Answer B

    74. mohammad hossein heidari says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    75. Eirini says:

      B.Mucoid degeneration of the ACL.

    76. cojocaru lucian says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    77. PGA says:

      answer B

    78. Luz Elena Guerrero Acosta says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    79. Hossameldin Ghanem says:

      B !

    80. ALBERT NICUSOR says:

      the correct answer is B.

    81. Raz says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    82. B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    83. Maja says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    84. Dr Catherine Johnson says:

      B: mucoid degeneration ACL

    85. Marta says:

      Mucoid degeneration

    86. Hana says:

      Mucoid degeneration of ant. cruciate ligament

    87. Andrés says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    88. Evangelos Alexiou says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    89. Klaus says:

      Mucoid degeneration ACL

    90. Naganathan Mani says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL.

    91. Bogna says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    92. Hugo Correia says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    93. jaime Saavedra says:

      mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    94. Dr Vipin Bakshi says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament is the most likely diagnosis.

    95. Adrian Pavel says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration ACL

    96. H Sahin says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    97. Stanislav Shevchenko says:

      It is mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    98. Sebastian says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    99. Mirza Spahic says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    100. K.W.van Muiswinkel says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    101. Stanley Ogoinja says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament.

    102. Jose Briceno says:

      Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament.

    103. Milka Kuka says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    104. Breaban Raluca says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    105. Amar Suri says:

      Celery stalk appearance of ACL suggestive of mucoid degeneration of acl…

    106. Amar Suri says:

      B.Mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    107. Farid Almasri says:

      Answer is B

    108. Alaa Khalil says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    109. Ahmed ElSharkawy says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    110. Diogo Castelo says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    111. Marjeta Tanka says:

      B.Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciat ligament

    112. Kamil Bekalarek says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    113. Roberto says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    114. Dr.Vishal Agrawal says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    115. Lekshmi T.P says:

      ans: B . celery stalk appearance of mucoid degeneration of ACL.

    116. Diana Zhekeeva says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    117. Halimat Akande says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    118. Mihai Gorun says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    119. javier says:

      degeneracion mucoide ligamento cruzado anterior

    120. Ruben Novoa says:

      I would like to see fibers between the mucoid, but I dont see them clearly. Without the age, other images and of course the clinic, it is difficult. But I choose B, mucoid degeneration. I dont see indirect signs to think in tear.

    121. Nafsika Korsavidou says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    122. Giancarlo Messalli says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    123. Yiken Karelys Ng Wong says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    124. Levente Lánczi says:

      My answer is B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    125. alireza sattar says:

      B. mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate lig.

    126. Stavros says:

      Mucoid degeneration of the anterior cruciate ligament

    127. Mohamed Abdelsadik says:

      B mucoid degeneration of anterior cruciate ligament

    128. Tarek Azzam says:

      B- Mucoid degeneration of the ACL.

    129. Florin MUSTE says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    130. Fares says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    131. Mohamed Kamel Ghanem Omar says:

      Answer is B.

    132. alaa algamel says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    133. HG says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    134. MAIJA says:

      Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    135. MAIJA says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    136. alaa algamel says:

      B. Mucoid degeneration of ACL

    137. Arash says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    138. shumaila arooj says:

      B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament

    139. Ferreiro says:

      B

    140. hajer alfadeel says:

      Answer B: mucoid degeneration of Anterior cruciate ligament

    141. jelena kostic says:

      The correct diagnosis is most likely B: Mucoid degeneration anterior cruciate ligament